The Truth About Board Game Kickstarters: Myths and Realities

Quick Answer

Board game Kickstarters can be a great way to discover innovative games, but they come with real risks. Not every project delivers on time or as promised. Understand the myths and realities before you back.

Board game crowdfunding has exploded in popularity, but with it come many misconceptions. Some believe Kickstarters are always cheaper or that you'll definitely get your game. Others think all crowdfunded games are risky. The truth is more nuanced.

In this article, we bust common myths about board game Kickstarters, using real examples from the industry. We'll help you make informed decisions, whether you're a seasoned backer or a newbie.

Myth 1: Kickstarter Games Are Always Cheaper

Many assume that backing a Kickstarter saves money compared to retail. While some projects offer early-bird discounts, others price their games at or even above retail to cover production and shipping. Shipping costs can be significant, especially for larger games.

For example, a game like Europa Base Alpha, with a retail price of $44.99, might seem like a deal on Kickstarter, but you must factor in shipping. Sometimes, retail prices drop later, making the Kickstarter not the cheapest option. Always compare total costs, including shipping, before backing.

• Compare the total Kickstarter pledge (including shipping) to the expected retail price.
• Check if the game will have a retail release; if so, you might wait for a sale.

Myth 2: You Will Definitely Receive Your Game

Crowdfunding is not a pre-order. When you back a project, you're investing in the creator's ability to produce the game. There's always a risk that the project fails, gets delayed, or never delivers. Even successful campaigns can face production issues.

Creators often share updates, but delays are common. A game that was supposed to arrive in six months might take two years. Before backing, research the creator's history and see if they've delivered on past projects. Look for experienced teams with transparent communication.

• Read the campaign's risks and challenges section.
• Check if the creator has successfully fulfilled previous Kickstarters.

Myth 3: Crowdfunding Games Are Lower Quality

Some people think that only games that can't find a publisher end up on Kickstarter. In reality, many successful crowdfunded games are high-quality and innovative. Kickstarter allows creators to take risks that traditional publishers might avoid.

For instance, games like Mr. Lovenstein Presents: No Context offer unique art and gameplay that might not fit mainstream publishers. The quality depends on the creator's dedication and experience, not the funding method. Many crowdfunded games go on to win awards and become bestsellers.

• Look for reviews of the creator's previous games.
• See if the campaign includes prototypes or gameplay videos.

Myth 4: You Get Exclusive Content Only on Kickstarter

Many campaigns offer Kickstarter-exclusive add-ons or stretch goals. This can be a perk, but it's not guaranteed. Some exclusives later become retail expansions or promo items. Also, exclusive content doesn't always enhance the core game.

For example, a game like Fairy Lights might offer a special promo card for backers, but the base game is complete and enjoyable without it. Don't back a game solely for exclusives; back it because you want to play the game.

• Consider if the exclusive content is worth the extra cost.
• Remember that the core game should be fun on its own.

Verdicts on Common Claims

• Claim: Kickstarter games are always cheaper: Reality: Not always. After shipping and potential retail discounts, you might pay more. Compare total costs before backing.
• Claim: Backing guarantees you get the game: Reality: There is always risk of delay or non-delivery. Research creator track record.
• Claim: Crowdfunded games are lower quality: Reality: Many are innovative and high-quality, but quality varies. Look for reviews and prototypes.
• Claim: Kickstarter exclusives are essential: Reality: Exclusives can be nice, but the core game should be your main reason. Back for the game, not just extras.

Real Game Examples

• Europa Base Alpha: There is no Cold War that is more chilling or isolated than on the untouched surface of Jupiter’s moon, Europa. The nations have broken apart and are now in a race to get defenses established on Europa before it is too late. This example shows a thematic, complex game that might appeal to backers looking for a deep experience. Its higher price point (retail $44.99) means shipping costs will be higher, so consider total cost.
• Fairy Lights: Fairy lights is a relaxing card game where you and your friends and family complete sets of identical bulbs in order to make the most beautiful garland and earn the most points. This is a lighter, family-friendly game that might be a good first Kickstarter. Its lower price point ($11) reduces financial risk, but still check for shipping and delivery timelines.

Board game Kickstarters offer exciting opportunities to support creators and get unique games, but they aren't risk-free. By understanding the myths and realities, you can make smarter backing decisions. Always do your research, budget for shipping, and back projects because you want to play the game, not just for the hype.