15 Men

The mutiny mechanic in this one had our whole table second-guessing each other by round three, which is exactly what I want from a hidden-role game. Plays great with five, though it moves fast enough that I'd happily run it with just three.

Didn't expect a bluffing game to work this well at two players, but the Captain versus scoundrel roles kept things tense the whole time. The mutiny mechanic where loyalties can flip mid-round had us second-guessing every vote.

Played this with five people and the scoundrel roles kept everyone guessing who was actually loyal to the Captain. The deception runs deep enough that you're second-guessing your own shipmates by the second round.